Thursday, February 5, 2009

--Guest Column by Raj Machhan

Heard about this one? A mobile social media start up in the US is notching up big community numbers by exploiting the individual fear of police speed traps. The service combines the power of social networking with the utility of mobile Location Based Services to come up with a potentially killer app that converts the cell phone into a virtual trap buster. A user spotting a speed trap, a police van, or any such ‘inconvenience’ simply needs to press a key on the mobile to announce the location of the trap to other members of the community – in real-time. Now, what makes this service a success?


You do not need to get into any technical mumbo-jumbo (in this case, the service has triangulation, assisted GPS and WPS at its core) or shell out huge money to any management guru to get the answer. While the technology and other related aspects are important, what really drives this service is the ingenuity of an open mind, a mind that spotted a latent need, conceived the service that could best meet this need and then went about implementing it with the conviction of a mad man.

This is not a standalone case. All of us part of the mobile VAS landscape, people who have spared a thought to what the future holds for this space, may speak in different tones on a lot many issues. But all of us could very well differ to agree on this: Unique ideas and innovation are going to draw the line between success and failure in this field like never before. We have seen it happening on the Web and now it is the turn of the mobile screen to feel the full frontal impact of the power of ideas. The industry is entering a period where the traditional business approach is set to give way to the supremacy of out of box thinking. The catch line of a recent ad put up by software major, perhaps, captures the context perfectly: What you think out of the box is what goes in the box (or mobile screen in this case).

The new wave in mobile VAS is fuelled by the maturing of Indian cellular markets, proliferation of technically advanced handsets, and the rapid progress made by the cellular networks. In India, the majority of the telecom circles now have multiple players and fresh competition comes knocking at the door. The cellular majors have matched each other on prices, service levels, technology, and service offerings. So how do you differentiate your brand? With unique value added services, of course!


The new wave mobile VAS will see the VAS players offer services directly to mobile users, and build up a brand in the process. The operator pipe is set to be commoditized in the manner somewhat similar to Internet bandwidth. How many of you remember the ISP companies that were once in the limelight, when access to adequate bandwidth was a major issue? The scenario is set to repeat itself in the mobile VAS arena.

Though it won’t be as easy as the Web, with standardization of technology, the development of VAS applications is set for a period of democratization. Just like the Web, where we have development frameworks like .Net and Java occupying the center stage, platforms such as J2ME, Symbian, Windows Mobile, and Android are now fast emerging as the standards for mobile applications. At the organization level, this means that the size of teams working on a project at any particular time will shrink further and the individual will be able to make a greater impact on the final shape.

What does this mean for the existing VAS players? Well for one, the best of breed companies will get a better shot at monetization of unique services. With less dependence on the intermediaries, the VAS players will be able to connect directly to the customers. This means that companies are in with a real chance to develop and implement billion-dollar apps like Facebook, Orkut, and You Tube. However, for this to happen, the thinking process will have to be mobile-centric, that is the focus needs to shift to applications conceived keeping the mobile screen at the core, instead of treating it as an extension of the Internet. The mobile phone has limited real estate compared to the PC, but it scores over the latter in other areas, with mobility being the obvious one. Plus, the mobile phone already has service- platforms such as SMS, IVR, USSD, WAP, that could be integrated for a holistic approach. Mobile-focused applications that leverage the inherent strengths of the mobile, and use the Internet as an extension of the mobile at best, is clearly the way forward if the VAS players are to score big.

Second, the existing players will need to get more flexible and go with the agile approach, which calls for quick turnaround for development, innovation, and iteration through direct interface with the customers.
Thirdly, the companies will need to steadily move towards changing the traditional operator-oriented mind-set and adopt a fresh approach that keeps the end-user at the core from the word go. Concepts like mental modeling, user profiling, schematics, information architecture and usability will need to be incorporated more prominently during application development.
Fourth, the VAS players will need to look at new revenue models. As of now, Subscription-based revenue models appear to be the best-fit in the changed scenario.

In the long run, organizations that are able to better exploit their key learning’s and leverage existing strengths to adapt to the changing environment are likely to emerge as the winners. As Dylan would say: You better learn to swim, lest you sink like a stone, For the times they are a changin’…..

7 comments:

  1. In the Indian context, what could be the most effective way to capture consumer mindspace through mobile VAS? This given the fact that the majority of people still have low-end handsets and are generally not very mobile savvy.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have been following mobile vas for quite some time now, but never heard of the writer. Anyways, it is a very well written post. The analysis is crisp.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Prince,

    Thanks so much for having liked and commented on the article. Raj is a colleague and has started contributing of late on this.

    Glad you liked it.

    Regards

    Saket

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Sudheer,

    Educating masses indeed is a huge pain area for the VAS industry. Conventional channel (retail outlet selling connections) and specialised VAS outlets would go a long way to educate & sell. They are the ones most connected with masses, who have to recharge every month.

    Low-end handsets are ideal for Voice based VAS offering and thats something which is picking up the most as it allow any handset to access VAS and in the language masses understand.

    Regards

    Saket

    ReplyDelete
  5. Very Informative post with lots of insights.
    I am also firm believer in the open mindedness approach for a product development in VAS arena and I think along the same line, moving from "Me Too" service to some world class novel ideas, the whole paradigm needs to be shifted instead of just adopting one or two methods.
    As rightly said "Latent Need”, which seems to be the driving force for most of the unique yet simple products in the market place, needs to be understood.
    For example "Twitter" which might have come out of, a latent need, to let world know what are you up to, is enough to create a millions of users ready to do the same.
    Although Apart from these International phenomenons, I think India needs to do more in terms of creating an Innovation Culture which at the end of the day is responsible for most popular services out there in Mobile VAS, we can't sustain this kind of growth forever on just "Me Too" services.
    One approach, as rightly mentioned by Raj is, by thinking in terms of giving mobile specific application instead of just copy pasting (which is proving NOT to be very successful even for major player) the successful web application onto mobile.
    Also to add to the ideas to give a push to the innovative applications, is to let user involve in the process as early as possible.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Very Informative post with lots of insights.
    I am also firm believer in the open mindedness approach for a product development in VAS arena and I think along the same line, moving from "Me Too" service to some world class novel ideas, the whole paradigm needs to be shifted instead of just adopting one or two methods.
    As rightly said "Latent Need”, which seems to be the driving force for most of the unique yet simple products in the market place, needs to be understood.
    For example "Twitter" which might have come out of, a latent need, to let world know what are you up to, is enough to create a millions of users ready to do the same.
    Although Apart from these International phenomenons, I think India needs to do more in terms of creating an Innovation Culture which at the end of the day is responsible for most popular services out there in Mobile VAS, we can't sustain this kind of growth forever on just "Me Too" services.
    One approach, as rightly mentioned by Raj is, by thinking in terms of giving mobile specific application instead of just copy pasting (which is proving NOT to be very successful even for major player) the successful web application onto mobile.
    Also to add to the ideas to give a push to the innovative applications, is to let user involve in the process as early as possible.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Peter Drucker introduced the term 'knowledge economy'. It essentially implies either:
    1. Knowledge economy - system for optimal production & management of knowledge facing 'economic' constraints (product)
    2. Knowledge-based economy - knowledge technology affecting economic benefits (service)
    Critics argue that the basis of such an economic model will essentially negate the very basic clause of traditional economic theories - that of scarcity of resources, in knowledge economy this very constraint doesn't exist.

    However, under traditional competitive market theory what affects the transition and evolution of markets is dissemination of market info on both buyer & supplier side. If evolution of market is an unavoidable phenomenon to achieve an equilibrium scenario, this basic model emphasizes the increasing importance of market information/knowledge ('informed decision making by buyers and sellers') over time. This may seem to be speaking in support of Drucker's insight that the ‘experiential economy’ is undergoing transition into ‘knowledge economy’. Theorists profess that in the present global economic scenario we are looking at just the start of a ‘supply-driving-demand’ situation.

    All of these indicate the increasing need of a generic 'knowledge hub' based on following main features:
    1. Single point convergence of information
    2. Intelligent system for accessing and disseminating relevant info in minimum time
    3. Remote/universal accessibility of this ready information

    According to me, the next generation VAS is looking to be the frontrunner to address the third feature. Within the domain, the key differentiator for players would be:
    1. Need Identifiers – end-consumer/mobile user orientation of marketing & sales force
    2. R&D – utilizing the most open platform to create which address the need gaps identified

    The fear of diminishing margins can be addressed by selective utilization of platforms based on the elements of each need:
    a. Basic need with greater reach – volume dependent and hence cost-effective; at present addressed by Voice, USSD and Text in order of maximum reach
    b. High-end product with niche market – higher value for quality rich information; at present Downloadable Applets and WAP

    However, in Indian context, this is dependent on when the market matures. The ideal situation will require changes on both operator and MTES (Mobile Technology Enabled Solution) providers:
    1. Operator:
    a. Upgrade infrastructure drastically
    b. Look at a long-term perspective of the network becoming a singular confluence of services which will derive inherent value
    2. MTES:
    a. Making R&D the USP and forte
    b. Stopping collective devaluation of customized services for the sake of competitiveness

    Will like to know your views on the same…

    ReplyDelete